Payment Processor Fee Comparison

Stripe vs PayPal for Recurring Subscriptions — Which Costs Less?

Side-by-side fee comparison of Stripe and PayPal for monthly subscription billing — with monthly and annual billing examples and a break-even calculator.

For subscription businesses, the choice between Stripe and PayPal comes down to fees, reliability, and feature depth. Here's the full comparison.

Fee comparison for monthly subscriptions

Both processors charge their standard transaction fee on every renewal:

On a $49/month plan, Stripe saves $2.88/year per subscriber vs PayPal Standard. At 1,000 subscribers that's $2,880/year just from the rate difference.

Subscription features: Stripe wins

Stripe Billing is purpose-built for SaaS: proration, metered billing, trial periods, pause subscriptions, and dunning (automatic retry on failed payments). PayPal's subscription APIs are functional but lack the same depth and reliability.

PayPal's chargeback rate for digital subscriptions is also higher than Stripe's — a critical factor because too many chargebacks can freeze your account.

Use our comparison calculator

Enter your monthly plan price in the Payment Fee Comparison to see the exact monthly savings of switching between processors for your subscription amount.

↑ Back to calculator

Stripe vs Shopify Payments — When Shopify Payments Is Actually Cheaper

Shopify Payments can be cheaper than Stripe for ecommerce stores — this guide shows the exact volume thresholds and when each processor wins.

Shopify Payments and Stripe look similar on the surface — both powered by Stripe's infrastructure — but the fee structures are meaningfully different for Shopify merchants.

The core difference: the Shopify gateway surcharge

If you use Stripe directly on Shopify (not Shopify Payments), Shopify charges an additional transaction fee on top of Stripe's fees: - Basic plan: +2.0% - Shopify plan: +1.0% - Advanced plan: +0.5%

This makes Stripe significantly more expensive for Shopify merchants than Shopify Payments.

Rate comparison: Shopify Payments vs Stripe on Shopify

For a Basic Shopify store ($39/mo) at $10,000/month volume:

Shopify Payments saves $295/month at $10k volume — easily covering the $39/mo plan cost.

When Stripe outside Shopify is better

If you're not selling on Shopify, Stripe is the better choice: - Better APIs for custom checkout - Superior subscription billing - Better international coverage - No platform dependency

Compare the exact fees for your transaction amounts with our Payment Fee Comparison.

↑ Back to calculator

PayPal Fees for Online Payments — Full Breakdown

PayPal charges 2.99–3.49% + $0.49 for online transactions. Here's the full fee breakdown, when PayPal is competitive, and when it isn't.

PayPal has two main pricing tiers for online card acceptance: PayPal Standard at 2.99% + $0.49 and PayPal Checkout (the branded button) at 3.49% + $0.49. The difference matters for SaaS and subscription businesses where the fixed $0.49 fee erodes margin on smaller transactions.

When does PayPal make sense?

PayPal's main advantage is buyer trust — shoppers who see the PayPal button often complete purchases they'd otherwise abandon, especially at checkout. A Baymard Institute study found PayPal reduces guest checkout abandonment by up to 14% versus form-only checkout.

If your average order value is above $30 and you're in direct-to-consumer e-commerce, the conversion uplift can more than offset the higher fee rate compared with Stripe.

How PayPal fees compare on a $100 payment

On $100 Stripe saves $0.28–$0.78 per transaction. At 1,000 transactions/month that's $280–$780/month — which compounds quickly at scale.

PayPal and subscriptions

PayPal Billing Agreements allow recurring charges without requiring the customer to approve each payment. However, subscription management (prorations, upgrades, dunning) is more limited than Stripe Billing. For pure SaaS, Stripe's developer tooling and webhook reliability are generally preferred.

PayPal's cross-border advantage

PayPal has local acquiring in 40+ countries and handles multi-currency settlement natively. If a significant portion of your customers are international, PayPal's conversion rates can be competitive with Stripe's international card fees (+1.5% for non-US cards).

Use the Payment Fee Comparison to plug in your average transaction amount and see the exact dollar difference for your situation.

↑ Back to calculator

How to Reduce Stripe Fees — 5 Practical Methods

Stripe charges 2.9% + $0.30 by default. Here are five concrete ways to lower your effective Stripe rate — from annual billing to volume negotiation.

Stripe's standard rate of 2.9% + $0.30 is fixed for most businesses. But the effective rate you actually pay depends on how you structure your billing and how much volume you process. Here are five concrete methods to bring it down.

1. Switch from monthly to annual billing

On a $99/month plan, Stripe charges the fee 12 times — $3.17 per renewal = $38.04/year. On an equivalent $990 annual plan, you pay the fee once: $29.01. You save $9.03 per subscriber per year just by switching billing cadence, while also improving cash flow.

2. Increase average transaction size

The $0.30 fixed component hits hardest on small transactions. At $5 it represents 6%, at $50 it's 0.6%, at $500 it's 0.06%. Bundling, annual plans, and minimum order values all reduce the per-dollar impact of the fixed fee.

3. Use Stripe's Optimized Checkout Suite

Stripe's Link (one-click checkout) typically increases conversion rates 7–30% with no additional fee. Higher conversion means more revenue at the same processing cost — your effective cost per dollar of revenue drops.

4. Negotiate volume pricing

Stripe offers custom pricing for businesses processing over $80,000/month (approximately $1M/year). The discount varies but is typically 0.2–0.5% below the standard rate. Contact Stripe sales once you approach that threshold — they will negotiate.

5. Route ACH payments separately

Stripe charges only 0.8% (capped at $5.00) for US bank transfers (ACH). If your customers are US-based businesses, offering ACH as a payment method for invoices above ~$500 slashes effective fees significantly. At $1,000 the fee is $5 (0.5%) vs $29.30 for a card.

What you can't reduce

Stripe's fee is non-negotiable for most businesses below $1M/year. Switching processors entirely (to Shopify Payments, Paddle, or a local acquirer) may save more than optimization — use the Payment Fee Comparison to see exact numbers for your average transaction size.

↑ Back to calculator

Lowest Payment Processing Fees for Small Business (2026)

Stripe, PayPal, and Shopify Payments compared for small business. Which processor has the lowest fees for your average transaction size?

For most small businesses, the three dominant payment processors are Stripe, PayPal, and Shopify Payments. Which one is cheapest depends almost entirely on your average transaction size and your monthly volume.

Fee comparison at a glance (2026)

The break-even thresholds

Shopify Basic vs Stripe: Shopify Basic ($39/mo plan) costs the same as Stripe at roughly $3,900/month in volume (the $39 monthly fee offsets savings of ~1%). Above that, Shopify Basic is cheaper; below it, Stripe wins.

Shopify vs Stripe at $100/transaction:

Which should you choose?

• Under $2,000/month volume → Stripe (no monthly fee, best developer experience)
• eCommerce on Shopify → Shopify Payments (lower rates, no external transaction fee)
• Consumer-facing with high cart abandonment → PayPal (conversion uplift offsets rate)
• Over $80,000/month → negotiate with Stripe or evaluate Stripe vs Paddle/FastSpring

Plug your average transaction amount into the Payment Fee Comparison to see exact fees and the cheapest option for your specific situation.

↑ Back to calculator